Question: Hi again, Greg,
I know I keep coming back to you with questions, but your answers make a lot of sense.
Simple, plain and to the point. Keep up the good God-inspired work. My question: What
determines long hair on men and where does it become sinful (ashamed)?
Thanks and God bless.
Dennis
Answer: Dennis,
There are several ways to look at this passage in 1 Cor. 11:14:
- The "permissible/acceptable length of a mans hair is culturally conditioned,
and not one absolute specific length that is defined here.
- "Nature teaches you" that is nature is something which
is intuitive, or of the conscience. This nature might be subjectively understood
within limits. That is, the meaning of the passage would be that nature (the
customs and mores of your own culture) teaches you what is dishonorable for
a man. Proponents of this view would cite the passage in the old covenant
which prohibits men and women from wearing anything that pertains to the
other and then point out that in the past, literalists have used
that passage that women should not wear jeans, trousers, etc. since those "clearly
pertain to a man." Problem is that some scholars say that women at the time
that passage was written may have worn a trouser-like garment to ensure modesty
while stooping and bending over, kneeling down, etc. as they worked in the
fields, in the home, etc. while men may have worn a loose fitting robe, more
like a womans dress today.
The actual passage about clothing is a prohibition against transvestites.
- "Nature teaches you" can be understood in more of a concrete,
exact and objective way. Paul uses the term this way in Romans 1, when speaking
of the inner conscience or moral law. If this is the intended meaning of
this passage, a loose rendering would be
"common sense ought to tell you that men and women ought to be distinguished
by the length of their hair."
The general idea that we derive from this passage is that there should be no gender
confusion, that men ought to clearly be men, and women, women. Specifics are not being
prescribed.
Hope this helps, Dennis.
In Christ,
Greg Albrecht